On the former Collin Creek Mall site, where US-75 meets Plano Parkway, three builders are putting up townhomes next to 8.9 acres of city-owned parkland and 1.6 miles of new walking trails. The builders are Ashton Woods, DRB Homes and Mattamy Homes, and the site is planned for about 500 attached single-family homes, along with 2,300 apartments and 300 independent living residences. It is also where Plano's builder rate promotions are being advertised this fall, and that helps explain how Plano's resale market behaved.
Resale values per square foot slipped this fall in Frisco, Allen and McKinney. Plano has very little land left to build on, and its value per square foot barely moved.
The square-foot number, city by city
The median sale price gets the headlines, but it shifts with whichever homes happen to close in a given month. Median price per square foot is closer to a like-for-like measure. The NTREIS Monthly MLS Summary Report for October 2026 was prepared by the Texas Real Estate Research Center at Texas A&M and released Nov. 7. Here is what it shows for single-family homes, October 2025 against October 2026.
| City | Median $/sq. ft., Oct. 2025 | Median $/sq. ft., Oct. 2026 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Plano | $215.14 | $213.79 | -0.6% |
| Richardson | $220.18 | $219.68 | -0.2% |
| Prosper | $251.99 | $246.00 | -2.4% |
| McKinney | $200.24 | $189.60 | -5.3% |
| Allen | $212.96 | $198.84 | -6.6% |
| Frisco | $246.80 | $222.90 | -9.7% |
Plano and its southern neighbor Richardson held nearly flat over those twelve months. Frisco's value per square foot fell by almost a tenth. Allen and McKinney landed in between.
The median prices alone would point the wrong way. McKinney's October median rose from $450,000 to $475,000, about 5.6%, over the same year in which its price per square foot fell 5.3%. In September, Frisco's median rose 3.0% to $669,500 year over year while its price per square foot dropped 4.8%. In both cases the median moved with the mix of homes that happened to close, while each square foot sold for less.
Plano's own median shows the same mix effect. Its October median rose from $505,700 to $520,000, and its average sale price climbed from $594,422 to $647,569, so October's 160 closings leaned toward pricier homes. The 0.6% dip per square foot is the better read of what a given Plano house was worth this fall compared with last.
Why the land runs out before the buyers do
Plano Director of Planning Christina Day told Community Impact in July 2025 that the city had 4% of its land undeveloped, or 1,863 acres as of January 2025. She said Plano's residential development "occurred largely from the 1960s through the year 2000." In the same article she described the city's approach to adding homes: rezoning commercial sites for residential use, with Collin Creek as the example. The city partnered with the developers at Collin Creek and at Haggard Farm to set up public improvement districts.
That history decides who a Plano seller competes with. A detached resale home in West Plano or along the older east-side streets is mostly up against other resale homes of a similar age. Many of those were built in the decades Day described, which is why build year matters as much as location in Plano, as we covered in our post on Plano homes and the year they were built. In Frisco, Prosper or McKinney, a resale seller often has a model home nearby with a sales team and a rate promotion. We traced that kind of pressure in Allen's golf-course neighborhood in an earlier post.
What the builders are advertising at Collin Creek
The builder competition Plano does have sits on one site and comes in one product type. In mid-November, Ashton Woods lists Collin Creek townhome plans from $445,000 to $550,000, at 1,520 to 2,413 square feet, under a banner advertising a 3.99% fixed rate, 4.33% APR. Mattamy Homes lists Collin Creek townhomes from 1,470 to 3,129 square feet, with floorplans starting at $460,000 and running up to $618,990. Mattamy is also advertising an FHA 5/1 ARM at 4.75%, 6.43% APR, through its affiliated lender, Mattamy Home Funding, described as "Going on Now."
For comparison, Freddie Mac's survey put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11% for the week of Nov. 12, 2026, up from 6.24% a year earlier. Builder rates are promotions with their own terms and dates. This is general market information, not financial advice, so confirm any rate or loan terms with your own lender.
The Collin Creek price band sits right around Plano's $520,000 October median. A buyer whose budget is near the citywide midpoint and who is open to a townhome has a real choice between a resale house at market rates and a new attached home with a builder-arranged rate. A buyer who wants a detached house with a yard faces no new-construction alternative inside Plano. Builder rate pressure reaches only part of Plano's market.
The next addition is also attached. Plano's Planning and Zoning Commission approved a preliminary plat for 187 townhomes at Haggard Farm, at Spring Creek Parkway and Windhaven Parkway, on Jan. 5, 2026, Local Profile reported. CandysDirt reported in November that the project broke ground in December 2025 and is targeting 188 townhomes for summer 2028.
The figure that cuts the other way
Plano's per-square-foot value held, but its pace slowed. Pending sales in Plano fell from 187 in October 2025 to 118 in October 2026, a drop of about 37%. New listings went from 271 to 220, and median days on market rose from 49 to 52. Pending contracts turn into the closings of the next month or two. The October drop shows up across the county, too: McKinney's pendings fell from 225 to 141 and Frisco's from 189 to 110 over the same twelve months.
So fewer buyers signed contracts in Plano, McKinney and Frisco alike. What sets Plano apart is that sellers there have not had to cut as much per square foot to meet them. Plano's supply stayed tight as the pace slowed. Active listings fell from 671 to 598 year over year in October, and months of inventory eased from 3.5 to 3.3. Frisco had 4.7 months of inventory and Prosper 6.4 in the same report. In September, Plano's 95.0% sold-to-list ratio was the highest among the Collin County cities in the report, and Prosper's was 90.1%. In October, Plano sellers got 94.0% of list price, Allen sellers 94.6%, and Frisco and McKinney sellers about 92%.
Reading this as a buyer comparing cities
A buyer weighing Plano against Frisco or McKinney this winter is comparing two kinds of negotiation. In the cities that are still building, part of the discount is the rate, and it comes from the builder. Resale sellers there compete with it by giving up price. In Plano, outside Collin Creek, the negotiation is almost entirely about price and terms between two owners. The per-square-foot numbers suggest Plano sellers have had less reason to give ground.
Value per square foot also carries forward. Plano's held through a year in which the 30-year average rose from 6.24% to 7.11% and pending sales fell, and limited land is a large part of why. A move-up family planning to stay a decade can weigh that alongside this month's list price. Sellers face the mirror image, since a valuation that leans on the median alone can understate or overstate a home depending on which houses closed nearby. A home valuation is a reasonable place to test that against recent sales.
A few distinct questions
Do falling pending sales mean Plano prices will drop next? Pendings are the earliest signal, and Plano's fell about 37% year over year in October. The November figures in the next NTREIS report will show whether those fewer contracts closed at lower prices per square foot or held.
Why isn't Celina in the comparison? The NTREIS report counts only sales made through the MLS. Sales by home builders outside the MLS are excluded. Celina recorded 10 MLS single-family sales in October 2026, so its numbers mostly leave out the new homes that make up much of that market.
Will Haggard Farm change the picture for detached homes? The 188 townhomes targeted for summer 2028 add to Plano's attached supply. Like Collin Creek, they compete most directly with resale homes near the citywide median.
If you are deciding between a Plano resale house, a Collin Creek townhome with a builder rate, or a newer home farther north, Vesta Schneider can lay out the per-square-foot comparables and the full cost of each option side by side before you commit. You can also start with our Plano neighborhood guide. Let's Connect.